Aruna Sankaranarayanan

First published in The Hindu, 1 Nov 2026

Though many Indians believe in fate and the laws of karma, these beliefs don’t
necessarily permeate our everyday lives. We usually go about our daily routines, make plans
and chart longer-term goals as if we have control over our actions. Only when misfortune or
a calamity strikes, do we fall back on a fatalistic worldview that things are actually beyond
our pale. In an article in Psyche, Tara-Lyn Camilleri, an evolutionary biologist, asks us to
perform an unusual experiment. For the next two week, live your life as if everything is
fated. Pretend that people don’t have free will and that life simply unfolds according to the
whims of fate.

Offbeat experiment:

The reason Camilleri asks us to engage in this offbeat exercise stems from her own personal experience. While she believes “we have agency,” “our will to act” is itself influenced by an interplay of genetic and environmental forces, instead of being “freely chosen.” She came to this conclusion when a parasitic infection she contracted during field work made her “chronically ill.” Unlike earlier, her own “effort and determination” did not yield the results she desired. As this experience has altered her worldview, she coaxes us to disband our belief in free will temporarily.

How might that impact us? As we interact with people over the course of a day, we tend to attribute their behaviour to their personality traits rather than their circumstances. This bias is called the fundamental attribution error and is noticeable especially when things go wrong. If we commit a mistake, we tend to ascribe blame to the situation we are in. If we overtake someone by taking a dangerous turn, we excuse our poor driving to being under stress. However, if someone else does this to us, we call them reckless.

We judge others for their wrongdoings or shortcomings with a less charitable lens than towards our own misdeeds or weaknesses. Whether it’s a person trying to get to work on time, lose weight, kick an addiction habit or pay off loans, we assume that people’s actions result from their choices. By leaving home earlier, opting for healthy foods, refusing alcohol or saving enough, a belief in free will predisposes us to think that these acts are in our control. 

Multiple forces:

When we put the entire onus of choices on individuals, we ignore both genetic and systemic causes that are beyond their control. When something goes wrong, we should ask what constellation of factors resulted in a particular outcome rather than point a finger at a particular person.

            Taking a big picture view allows us to zero in on the multiple forces that impel a person’s behaviour—from their unique genetic endowment to their upbringing to their social, economic and cultural backgrounds to the immediate stressors in their present environment.

According to Camilleri, we need to adopt a more balanced and nuanced approach when viewing people’s actions. We recognize that ‘choice’ itself is not completely within every person’s control but rather a ‘convergence’ of a multiplicity of factors. Rather than endorsing either total free will or a completely deterministic outlook, we could recognize that we have freedom within limits, and each person is constrained in different ways.

We are conditioned to believe that “grit guarantees progress,” says Camilleri. But through her illness, she realized that effort does not always lead to favourable outcomes. As a result, she has become less judgmental and doesn’t automatically blame people when things go awry. Instead, she pauses and asks herself what factors may have contributed to a particular outcome. Rather than blaming and shaming, she adopts a problem-solving stance, resulting in a more impartial and level-headed outlook. Perhaps, we can all gain from this exercise.

(The author is Visiting Faculty, School of Education, Azim Premji University & the co-author of Bee-witched.)